Taste is a muscle, not a gift
- Published
- October 14, 2026
- Topic
- Taste
- Reading
- 6 min
- Written by
- Maren Holt
Why I copy old posters by hand on Friday afternoons, and what it has taught me about choosing.
People talk about taste as if it were handed out at birth, like perfect pitch or freckles. In my experience it behaves much more like a muscle. It gets stronger when you use it on purpose, and it wastes away surprisingly quickly when you stop.
For the last four years I have kept a small Friday ritual. Late in the afternoon, when client emails have slowed down, I pick a poster I admire — usually something printed before I was born — and copy it by hand. Not traced, not scanned. Copied, with a pencil and a ruler and a lot of rubbing out.
Copying is a way of asking questions
You cannot copy a layout without noticing every decision inside it. Why is the headline set slightly smaller than I expected? Why does the date sit a full line lower than the name of the venue? Why does the red only appear twice?
When I look at a poster, I take it in as a whole. When I copy one, I have to take it apart. The designer's choices stop being invisible, and a few of them start to become mine.
Taste is mostly the memory of a thousand small decisions you have already watched someone else make well.
Choosing is the real skill
The surprising lesson of the Friday copies is that good design is rarely about having more ideas. It is about choosing between them with conviction. The posters I return to most are almost rude in how much they leave out.
That is now the first thing I bring to a new identity project. Before we sketch, we write a short list of things the brand will never do. It is the most useful page in every brief I have ever written.
A small exercise
If you want to try this, start with something simple: a book jacket, a stamp, a record sleeve. Give yourself an hour and no screens. Copy it as accurately as you can, then write down three decisions you would not have made yourself.
Do it again next week. Taste, like any muscle, prefers repetition to inspiration.